• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header left navigation
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to after header navigation
  • Skip to site footer
  • Home
  • Books
All Geek Things and All She Wrote

All Geek Things

Random thoughts of a crowded mind

  • Reviews
  • Xena
  • Blog

General

  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • About

Categories

  • Home
  • Features
  • Reviews
    • Loved you in this
  • TV & films
  • Xena
  • Pop culture
  • Business & marketing
  • Writing
  • Bookish
  • Random thoughts
  • Home
  • Features
  • Reviews
    • Loved you in this
  • TV & films
  • Xena
  • Pop culture
  • Business & marketing
  • Writing
  • Bookish
  • Random thoughts

New Amsterdam – A show about an immortal homicide detective

11 March, 2008 by PashaO
Nikolaj Coster-Waldau as detective John Amsterdam

New Amsterdam stars Danish actor Nikolaj Coster-Waldau as immortal homicide detective John Amsterdam. I discovered this intriguing series whilst hunting for something new to watch.

With Stargate Atlantis nearing the end of its fourth season, Smallville and Supernatural are on a break I’ve been hunting around for something to fill the time. Battlestar Galactica isn’t set to return for another month, so what’s a girl to do but hunt around for the next new thing.

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau




Peppered with flashbacks at first blush you’d be thinking Highlander rip off, but New Amsterdam is as different as it is similar. John’s immortality is a gift/curse from a Native American woman whose life he saved by stepping in front of a sword. She heals him and curses him with these words: “You will not grow old, you will not die, until you find the one, and your souls are wed.” This means he can’t die until he finds his soul mate. After 400 years he’s still looking.

Like Highlander, he has a friend Omar (Stephen Henderson) who runs a jazz bar and knows his secret. Unlike Highlander John can have children and over the years he’s had a fair few. John has been many things in 400 years and luckily for his friend he was a celebrated furniture maker in a former life. In the first episode, we see John make a desk for his friend who sells it as an antique for $60.000.

If I had to compare it to another TV series, I’d say it is more like the Buffy spin-off Angel in the fact that John has a weekly crime to investigate with his partner Eva Marquez (Zuleikha Robinson) but when he’s not doing that he’s looking for “The One”. He is looking forward to a day when he can grow old and die because then life will have meaning. It’s similar to Angel’s hope that the Shanshu Prophecy that foretells the restoration of a vampire with a soul into a mortal human being, is all about him.




Whether it’s a mashup of Angel and Highlander or not, New Amsterdam is worth a look in if you liked the premise of either of those shows. The first two episodes have enough twists and turns to reel you in. Like, when you find out about his son. I couldn’t help thinking about the implications of growing old, knowing that your father would always look the same. And the fact that if he’s still searching for “The One”, what does that mean for all the women that have gone before?

If like me you’ve been reeled in by shows that subsequently get cancelled then jump on board now because New Amsterdam does have the air of a soon to be cancelled show. Not to jinx it or anything, it’s a gut feeling.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
Reviews TV

You May Also Like…

Avatar The Last-Airbender Cast-Miya Cech as Toph

Toph, but make Her “slightly more feminine”: Why fans are worried about Netflix’s Avatar reboot

Apple TV series Severence

Severance Season 1 review: Corporate hell, but make it existential

Doctor Who Rogue episode promo

Doctor Who’s future uncertain as Ncuti Gatwa reportedly plans exit

The Wheel Of Time Season 3 Trailer reveals Moiraine's prophetic torment

The Wheel Of Time Season 3 Trailer reveals Moiraine’s prophetic torment

Reader Interactions

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Sidebar

stars in the outer space

Gary Bloom’s cosmic vision: Antares Ascended

Babylon 5 the road home

2023: Year in review

Trending

  • The evolution of musical episodes in television
    The evolution of musical episodes in television
  • Hercules and Xena Crossover Episodes
    Hercules and Xena Crossover Episodes
  • Xena: Warrior Princess - Ties That Bind
    Xena: Warrior Princess - Ties That Bind
  •  Babylon 5 star Jerry Doyle has died
     Babylon 5 star Jerry Doyle has died
  • The Wheel Of Time Season 3 Trailer reveals Moiraine's prophetic torment
    The Wheel Of Time Season 3 Trailer reveals Moiraine's prophetic torment
  • Xena: Warrior Princess - Callisto Episodes
    Xena: Warrior Princess - Callisto Episodes

Socials

  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2025 · All Geek Things · All Rights Reserved

 

Loading Comments...